Budget 2016: Will Arun Jaitley residence taxation hurdles in a M&A domain?

24 views Leave a comment

By Saumil Shah

The courtesy expects a bill to supplement a new shade to a Merger and Acquisition (MA) activities in India.

The nation witnessed one of a many colourful seasons of MA in 2015. Though a stairs taken by a supervision have helped urge financier notice towards India as good as a palliate of doing business in a nation to some extent, there exist certain bottlenecks that need obligatory attention.


In an epoch of globalisation, cross-border MA activities are common. While a merger/demerger between dual unfamiliar companies that have Indian investment is free from taxation theme to certain conditions, there is no such grant accessible with honour to merger/demerger between dual unfamiliar companies in that an Indian entity is a shareholder.

With several companies going tellurian and actively participating in MA activities, carrying specific supplies exempting such unfamiliar restructuring in a hands of Indian shareholders shall assistance a India courtesy revoke taxation cost of endeavour such activities outward India.

‘Earn-out’ structures are really common in MA. Investors currently are prepared to share an upside with promoters who continue to emanate resources for all. This upside is typically referred to as an ‘earn-out’.

Earn-out related payments are common in deals with promoters and are radically remuneration models where a customer agrees to compensate partial of a understanding care depending on a destiny opening of a business. There exists ambiguity around taxation of such earn-outs.

As per a prevalent taxation regime in India, sellers could potentially compensate taxation on a whole consideration, including an earn-out related remuneration perceived in future. This formula in money outflow of taxation that is not in suit to a money perceived by a sellers.

Further, there is no resource for recouping of taxation in a eventuality of any rebate in a altogether care in a future, contend on comment of under-performance of business.

The Indian taxation regime has special supplies for fatiguing deferred remuneration on a receipt basis, in box of mandatory partnership of land by a government. A identical judgment could also be introduced to yield a gainful taxation regime for earn-outs as well.

Earn-out related business models are prevalent internationally, and hence a Indian taxation regime should also recognize such blurb mandate and yield for suitable taxation diagnosis for earn-outs.

Non-compete payments are customarily one of a pivotal parameters in a deal. While these payments are taxable in a hands of a recipient, there are anomalous legal dominance as to either a taxpayer could get a taxation mangle on such payments.

Receiving clarity in this regard, could assistance a customer guess a effective taxation cost on a Internal Rate of Return (IRR), holding into care intensity taxation savings.

Contribution of a Indian services zone towards a Indian economy has been increasing. While a production zone is entitled to lift brazen taxation waste in a eventuality of a merger, such a advantage is not accessible for a services sector.

Considering a volume of MA activities in this sector, a Finance Minister might cruise fluctuating this advantage here as well.

There exists a inconsistency with honour to a duration of holding criteria for shares that are offering for sale in an Initial Public Offering (IPO) vis-à-vis listed shares.

As per a prevalent taxation regime, when shares are offering for sale in an IPO, such sale of shares validate as a long-term collateral item usually if a holding duration exceeds 36 months. Whereas, for listed shares, a criteria is 12 months.

Since a Securities Transaction Tax (STT) is done germane even in box of shares offering for sale in an IPO, this inconsistency might be streamlined.

Another plea faced by a MA courtesy is a requirement of receiving a Tax Clearance Certificate from Indian taxation authorities before to send of certain assets.

As per a requirement, such a certificate is compulsory before to transferring specified resources and in a deficiency of such a certificate a send could be regarded as blank by a taxation authorities. Obtaining such a certificate could be time immoderate and during times, impact a understanding timelines. The Finance Minister could cruise introducing a Safe Harbour Rules in propinquity to this requirement.

We wish that this Budget gives due care to all a above mentioned taxation hurdles in a MA domain, providing a required procedure to a expansion of a Indian economy.

The author is Partner, Tax, KPG in India. Nitesh Mehta, Director, Tax, KPMG in India contributed to a article. Views voiced are personal.