PM Modi offered Digital India in Silicon Valley is one thing, walking a speak in genuine India is another

267 views Leave a comment

Unlike Rahul Gandhi who trots out a now well-worn suit-boot taunt during each occasion, Narendra Modi’s speeches are tailor-made for his audience. His conventional debate of Silicon Valley was no difference as he bewitched a titans of record by vocalization their lingo. There’s zero that tech expert kids like improved than technological china bullets for clearly bullheaded amicable problems, aggressive poverty, as a Indian primary apportion said, by a energy of networks and mobile phones. If an American boss once betrothed a duck in each pot and a automobile in each garage, Narendra Modi served adult a digital chronicle of that guarantee – JAM for all, Jan Dhan bank account, Aadhaar cards and Mobile governance.

Free wi-fi during 500 railway stations. 600,000 villages related by visual twine network. What was not to love, or during slightest Facebook-like, about this prophesy of a destiny even yet it does not meant women’s rights are ensured or that medical is truly accessible. And Modi, a master of amicable media, was clearly in his component laying out a no-call-drop design of a other India –where Maharashtra farmers have WhatsApp groups and a existential choice is about iOs or Android. No consternation Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg pronounced “I altered my form design to support Digital India, a Indian government’s bid to bond farming communities to a Internet and give people entrance to some-more services online.”

Prime Minister Narendra Modi in US. PTIPrime Minister Narendra Modi in US. PTI

Prime Minister Narendra Modi in US. PTI

But FreeInternet does not interpret to leisure on a Internet. While Modi tells Zuckerberg “Social media helped me benefit knowledge, it broadened my horizon”, a irony is distant too many typical Indians find out a tough approach that that leisure is unequivocally a minefield. A university highbrow in Kolkata forwards a animation about Mamata Banerjee and is hauled off to jail. A tyro in UP posts something derogative about Samajwadi Party’s Azam Khan and faces 14 days legal remand. Two girls in Mumbai are arrested for doubt a city’s shutdown for Bal Thackeray’s wake on Facebook. Actually one was arrested for ‘liking’ a post. A small-time businessman in Puducherry was arrested for tweeting about Karti Chidambaram’s wealth. And notwithstanding a many blatant abuses of Section 66A of a IT Act, a BJP chose to try and urge it in justice instead of junking it and signaling a thespian mangle from a UPA days.

The PM spoke ringingly about a energy of amicable media in triggering change. “You get genuine time updates, we can come to know now when something happens in any dilemma of a world. And if a supervision is warning it can take this information to take visual measures.” He competence have been referring to his IT apportion Ravi Shankar Prasad’s new U-turn on a breeze offer about encryption and information confidence though a fact is a government, for all a amicable media proselytization, has frequency walked a talk. Modi competence contend humbly he found himself being prepared around amicable media, though his associate adults like Ambikesh Mahapatra, Shaheen Dada, Rinu Srinivasan, Aseem Trivedi, Kanwal Bharti perceived a opposite kind of preparation interjection to their experiments with amicable media. In roughly all these cases, it took courts to meddle on their behalf. And it is not like a travails of an Ambikesh Mahapatra done authorities consider twice before going after a Rinu Srinivasan either.

Given this lane record what soundness is there that where low cost Internet comes, Big Brother will never be distant behind? In that sense, Arvind Kejriwal has a indicate when he says Mr. Modi should concentration on creation India before revelation everybody to Make in India. While Modi attracts Silicon Valley by revelation them that Twitter has done everybody a contributor and Google has done teachers reduction awe-inspiring, he does not tell a flip side of that story where a leisure of countenance has not kept pace. As a PM basked in a internet leisure of Silicon Valley, an internet anathema was extended in a Kashmir valley. Quartz commented that a townhall in a finish “reeked of PR-scented prohibited air” since Modi was not pulpy on “key issues including India’s internet regulatory horizon and concerns over leisure of expression.”

Google’s Sundar Pichai substantially came closest, if inadvertently, to indicating out this opening when he pronounced “It is not only about being online, though what we do online.” That’s where a supervision has a prolonged approach to go if it unequivocally aims to live adult to a lofty ideals of Digital India that a PM summarized in Silicon Valley.

Otherwise notwithstanding his honeyed speak about JAM for all, a PM could finish adult sounding some-more like Lewis Carroll’s White Queen who offering Alice dual pence a week and jam each other day.

Alice couldn’t assistance laughing, as she said, “I don’t wish we to sinecure me – and we don’t caring for jam.”
“It’s really good jam,” pronounced a Queen.
“Well, we don’t wish any to-day, during any rate.”
“You couldn’t have it if we did wish it,” a Queen said. “The order is, jam to-morrow and jam yesterday – though never jam to-day.”