Simone Biles Should Not Be Compared to Nadia Comaneci

266 views Leave a comment


Simone Biles should not be compared to Nadia Comaneci. Both gymnasts won 5 medals in dual different Olympic competitions, though they should not be compared because one was some-more gracious, while a other has a improved technique.

The Romanian Gymnastics Legend

Comaneci is a Romanian contestant who was innate on Nov. 12, 1961, in Onesti, Romania. The gymnast done story during a 1976 Montreal Olympics when she became a initial contestant to accept a ideal measure of 10 in an Olympic gymnastics event. In Canada, when Comaneci was usually 14 years old, she won a sum of 5 medals; 3 gold, one silver, and one bronze. Due to her Olympic success, a gymnast was a 1976 BBC Sports Personality of a Year in a abroad athletes’ category. She also perceived inhabitant recognition.

Until 1981, When She Retired, Comaneci Won a Total of 30 Medals:

  • Biles21 gold: 5 during a 1976 and 1980 Olympics; 9 during a 1975, 1977 and 1979 European Championships; dual during a 1978 and 1979 World Championships; and 5 during a 1981 Summer Universiade.
  • Seven silver: 3 during a 1976 and 1980 Olympics; dual during a 1975 and 1977 European Championships; and dual during a 1978 World Championships.
  • Two bronze: one during a 1976 Olympics and one during a 1979 European Championships.

As a outcome of her measureless success, Comaneci is one of a best-known gymnasts in a world. Moreover, according to CNN, in 2000, a Laureus World Sports Academy named her as one of a Athletes of a Century.

After retiring, she became an general envoy for a foe that done her a legend. Currently, she lives in a United States, where she and her father Bart Conner, possess a gymnastics academy and several sports apparatus shops.

The American Phenomenon

Biles was innate on Mar 14, 1997, in Columbus, Ohio. She done story for a USA gymnastics group during a 2016 Rio Olympics when she won 5 medals; 4 bullion and one bronze. Biles is a initial contestant who won 4 Olympic bullion medals during a singular foe given 1984.

Throughout her career, Biles cumulative 23 medals, creation her a many flashy American gymnast:

  • 16 gold: 4 during a 2016 Olympics; 10 during a 2013, 2014 and 2015 World Championships; and dual during a 2016 Pacific Rim Championships.
  • Two silver: during a 2013 and 2014 World Championships.
  • Three bronze: one during a 2016 Olympics and dual during a 2013 and 2015 World Championships.

After her implausible opening in Rio, that placed her among a gymnastics elite, specialists compared Biles to Comaneci and other good athletes of all time, such as Larisa Latynina, Ecaterina Szabo, and Daniela Silivas. There were even voices that announced her a best gymnast ever.

An Impossible Comparison

However, a comparison between a 19-year-old American and her predecessors is unfit as gymnastics has come a prolonged way. The competitions hold 4 decades ago have few aspects in common with a ones orderly now, therefore, Biles should not be compared to Comaneci. From 1970-1980, a exercises were seemly and fluid, while currently, a accent is on a problem of a elements that harmonise a routines.

Moreover, it is transparent that Biles concentrates some-more on her strength. She puts energy in her routines to excite a audience. On a contrary, according to The Boston Globe, Comaneci vacant with “graceful, liquid movements and unmatched steadiness.”

Gymnastics Evolution

Over a final 50 years, gymnastics have developed enormously, along with a scoring system. Biles is not means to make a ideal 10, as Comaneci did in 1976. Currently, a final measure is a sum of a execution and problem scores. However, a Romanian gymnast, who knows something about a soundness of gymnastics, announced that Biles deserved a 10 for her building slight in Rio. Moreover, Comaneci endorsed that usually time would exhibit if a Romanian contestant is a best of all time. According to Indian Express, Comaneci settled that a building is a apparatus where a American proves her superiority.

Gymnastics have developed greatly, as it appears in a videos below, a exercises of Biles and Comaneci have few aspects in common. Therefore, there should not be a comparison between a dual .

The Romanian was a gymnast of a moment, 40 years ago, while a American is creation story right now. Each of them will sojourn in a gymnastics chronicles among other critical total of this friendly sport. Biles and Comaneci should share a wall of fame, not quarrel for a biggest spot.

Opinion News by Bianca-Ramona Dumitru
Edited by Jeanette Smith


The Boston Globe: Better on beam: Simone Biles in 2016 or Nadia Comaneci in 1976?
CNN: Nadia Comaneci
Fox Sports: How Simone Biles’ five-medal run in Rio compares with a best gymnasts of all time
Indian Express: Nadia Comaneci hails ideal 10 from Simone Biles
USA Today: Nadia Comaneci: Too shortly to contend Olympic champ Simone Biles biggest ever

Featured and Top Image Courtesy of Agência Brasil Fotografias’ Flickr Page – Creative Commons License
Inline Image Courtesy of Dave Gilbert’s Flickr Page – Creative Commons License

Simone Biles Should Not Be Compared to Nadia Comaneci combined by Bianca-Ramona Dumitru on Aug 17, 2016
View all posts by Bianca-Ramona Dumitru →

Like this: