Untangling a mechanics of knots

223 views Leave a comment

Got rope? Then try this experiment: Cross both ends, left over right, afterwards move a left finish underneath and out, as if restraining a span of shoelaces. If we repeat this sequence, we get what’s called a “granny” knot. If, instead, we cranky both ends again, this time right over left, you’ve combined a sturdier “reef” knot.


The configuration, or “topology,” of a tangle determines a stiffness. For example, a grandma tangle is many easier to undo, as a pattern of twists creates weaker army within a knot, compared with a embankment knot. For centuries, sailors have celebrated such distinctions, selecting certain knots over others to secure vessels — mostly by premonition and tradition.

Now researchers during MIT and Pierre et Marie Curie University in Paris have analyzed a automatic army underpinning elementary knots, and come adult with a speculation that describes how a knot’s topology determines a automatic forces.

The researchers carried out experiments to exam how many force is compulsory to tie knots with an augmenting series of twists. They afterwards compared their observations with their fanciful predictions, and found that a speculation accurately likely a force indispensable to tie a knot, given a topology and a hole and rigidity of a underlying strand.

“This is a initial time, to a best of a knowledge, that pointing indication experiments and speculation have been tied together to interpretation a change of topology on a mechanics of knots,” a researchers write in a paper appearing in a biography Physical Review Letters.

Pedro Reis, a Gilbert W. Winslow Career Development Associate Professor in Civil Engineering and Mechanical Engineering, says a new tangle speculation competence yield discipline for selecting certain tangle configurations for a given load-bearing application, such as braided steel cables, or surgical stitching patterns.

“Surgeons, of course, have a good understanding of experience, and they know this tangle is improved for this stitching procession than this knot,” Reis says. “But can we serve surprise a process? While maybe these knots are used, we competence uncover that some other knots, finished in a certain way, competence be preferable.”

A disfigured theory

Reis’ colleague, French theorist Basile Audoly, creatively took on a problem of relating a knot’s topology and automatic forces. In prior work, Audoly, with his possess co-worker Sébastien Neukirch, had grown a speculation formed on observations of tightening a really simple, overhand knot, comprising usually one twist. They afterwards accurate a speculation with a somewhat some-more formidable tangle with dual twists. The theory, they concluded, should envision a army compulsory to tie even some-more formidable knots.

However, when Reis, together with his students Khalid Jawed and Peter Dieleman, achieved identical experiments with knots of some-more than dual twists, they found that a prior speculation unsuccessful to envision a force indispensable to tie a knots. Reis and Audoly teamed adult to rise a some-more accurate speculation for describing a topology and mechanics of a wider operation of knots.

The researchers combined knots from nitonol, a hyper-elastic handle that, even when focussed during thespian angles, will lapse to a strange shape. Nitonol’s agility and rigidity are good known.

To beget several topologies, a researchers tied knots with mixed overhand twists, formulating increasingly longer braids. They afterwards clamped one finish of any plat to a table, used a automatic arm to concurrently lift a tangle tight, and totalled a force applied. From these experiments, they celebrated that a tangle with 10 twists requires about 1,000 times some-more force to tie than a tangle with usually one.

“When Pedro Reis showed me his experiments on knots with as many as 10 twists, and told me that they could conflict such a high force, this initial seemed to me to be distant over what elementary equations can capture,” Audoly says. “Then, we suspicion it was a good challenge.”

From shoelaces to surgery

To come adult with a speculation to envision a army observed, Reis and Audoly went by mixed iterations between a experiments and speculation to brand a mixture that mattered a many and facilitate a model. Eventually, they divided a problem in dual parts, initial characterizing a knot’s loop, afterwards a braid. For a initial part, a researchers quantified a aspect ratio, or figure of a loop, given a series of twists in a braid: The some-more twists in a braid, a some-more elliptical a loop.

The group afterwards complicated a army within a braid. As a braid, or twist, is symmetric, a researchers simplified a problem by usually deliberation one strand of a braid.

“Then we write an appetite for a complement that includes bending, tension, and attrition for that one scrolled strand, and we are means to establish a shape,” Audoly says. “Once we have a shape, we can compare it to this loop, and eventually we get a altogether force banishment response of a system.”

To exam a theory, Reis plugged a experiments’ measurements into a speculation to beget predictions of force.

“When we put a information by a machine of a theory, a predictions and a dataset all fall onto this master curve,” Reis says. “Once we have this master curve, we can give me a tortuous rigidity and hole of a strand, and a series of turns in a knot, and we can tell we what force is compulsory to tie it. Also, we now know how a tangle thatch itself adult when some-more turns are added.”

Reis envisions mixed applications for a group’s theory, both poignant and mundane.

“This speculation helps us envision a automatic response of knots of opposite topologies,” Reis says. “We’re describing a force it requires to tie a loop, that is an indicator of a rigidity of a knot. This competence assistance us to know something as elementary as how your headphones get tangled, and how to improved tie your shoes, to how a pattern of knots can assistance in surgical procedures.”

Source: NSF, Massachusetts Institute of Technology